In April, Brown proclaimed bankruptcy, a step that immediately stops any repossession action. That may have worked, except Brown has declared bankruptcy so often that Tampa bankruptcy Judge Catherine Peek McEwen finally had enough.
I discover and conclude that you are a serial violent bankruptcy filer, McEwen said in a current hearing, reading off a list of seven separate filings given that 2008. I am going to prohibit you for two full years from filing. Im sorry, Mr. Brown, youve just had too numerous chances.
Brown is amongst a growing legion of debtors who have been stated violent as judges get hard on people video gaming an overworked bankruptcy system. In the previous year and a half, a minimum of 85 Tampa Bay residents have actually been barred from refiling for up to 2 years after it became evident they declared bankruptcy mostly to obstruct repossession.
Another 25 bay location debtors whose bankruptcy cases are pending have been bought to reveal cause why they must not be proclaimed abusive filers.
Debtors currently disallowed from refiling include:
o A Palm Harbor couple who filed 11 bankruptcy petitions in 8 years to stop repossession. The bank got a final judgment versus them in 2007 however consistently had to cancel foreclosure auctions due to the fact that of all the filings.
o Another Palm Harbor couple who filed 18 bankruptcy petitions over a years. They had actually been living complimentary for 12 years prior to the bank lastly got a writ of possession in 2014.
o A Safety Harbor lady who has submitted 7 petitions considering that 2011, including 2 this year. She hasn’t made a mortgage payment in more than 6 years.
o o o
Tampa bankruptcy judges likewise are breakingpunishing non-lawyers who have actually prepared petitions for serial filers. To attract company, one preparer even boasted to prospective customers that he had actually proclaimed bankruptcy 6 times to block foreclosure on his own house.
McEwen, one of four bankruptcy judges in Tampa, stated serial filers are a drain on the system and cut into the time that court officials can spendinvest in debtors who fileapply for legitimate purposes.
My sense is that I do see it increasing, she said of abusive filings, though that might be because of the process we embeddeded in result where we are in fact taking a look at them. Before, they might have gotten dismissed under the radar screen and we judges wouldnt have actually seen that some had three or four or 5 filings.
There is no limit on how lots ofthe number of bankruptcy petitions a person can file. As soon as the petition is filed, an automatic stay takes impactworks barring banks and other creditors from tryingaiming to collect debts, including home loan financial obligations. At the same time the petition is submitted, nevertheless, the debtor is supposed to submit documents listing properties, liabilities and creditors.
Until a couple of years earlier, bankruptcy case managers rapidly dismissed cases missing out on the needed documentation. When creditors whined that cases were thrownthrown away prior to they even had time to hire a lawyer, I understood … individuals were sliding through the system with numerous filings and stays (of repossession) with no effects, McEwen said.
As a result, a treatment is now in location to catch any individual declaring bankruptcy for a third time. Judges can order the debtor to come to court and showjustify why he or she should not be declared an abusive serial filer and temporarily prohibited from refiling.
Thats exactly what occurred one morning this month when McEwen held three program cause hearings.
The very first case was that of Martin Prenatt, a Valrico male on his 4th bankruptcy filing in two years. Neither he nor his attorney showedappeared, and neither might be reached by phone. McEwen dismissed the case due to the fact that Prenatt hadnt filed the required documents on time, and banned him from refiling for two years.
Timothy Kemplin, a Gulfport guy who has stated bankruptcy three times considering that 2013, was up next.
He too failed to appear in individualpersonally, informing the judge by phone that he couldnt come due to the fact that it was raining and his automobiles windscreen wipers didnt work.
McEwen noted that Kemplin hadnt went to an earlier hearing either. He stated that was because his automobile had actually overheated.
Though sounding skeptical, the judge offered Kemplin till July to show he would be able to satisfy the requirements of his plan to repay lenders.
McEwen had no perseverance for Brown, the Spring Hill guy who was another no-show. Though he said by phone that his pre-2014 filings were to conserve his automobile from repossession, not his house, she chastised him for failing to send even the mostone of the most fundamental files with his most current petition.
By now, you have some training in doing exactly what ought to be done, McEwen stated as she stated him a serial abusive filer and banned him from refiling for two years.
The Times tries to reach Brown and Prenatt after their hearings were not effective. Kemplin, who has actually been in repossession since 2012, said he did not believe he was abusing the system: Im simply attemptingaiming to do exactly what I need to do.
In declaring debtors violent, McEwen and her coworkers concern orders that serve to inform state judges and notary of the refiling ban. In big, strong type the orders say that any bankruptcy petitions submitted within the duration of the ban will not stop any foreclosure sale.
o o o
It was such an order that permitted a sale to proceed this year on the Palm Harbor house of Marina and Guenter Tesch.
The now-divorced couple bought the residence in 2006 for $416,000 but defaulted on the home mortgage in less than a year. The bank foreclosed in 2007 however the repossession sale was canceled when Guenter Tesch filed the very first of what would be his seven bankruptcy petitions.
Tesch, however, didnt submit the needed files, so the case was dismissed and the sale was rescheduled. Over the following years, a pattern emerged. Tesch and his spouse would take turns filling petitions to obstruct the sale. The cases would be dismissed for numerous reasons. The sale would be rescheduled, one of the Tesches would file a brand-new petition, and so on.
Their luck ran out May 6 after Marina Tesch submitted her fourth petition, bringing the couples total to 11.
This court finds that the Debtor and the Debtors spouse … have taken part in a plan to delay, prevent and defraud (the bank) by several bankruptcy filings, Judge Rodney Might composed.
Might banned both Tesches from refiling for 2 years and let a scheduled sale go through. The bank now has the home 8 years after foreclosing.
Records reveal Tesch, born in Germany, and his ex-wife have been unemployed and supported by loved ones for several years. When the Times called him, he said he couldnt speak then; he did not call back or return a subsequent call.
With the Tesches lots of cases staggered in between 2 judges– May and McEwen– it was tough for either judge to find what was going on up until the system that tags three-time filers entered into result, McEwen said.
She and other judges also are getting difficult on some petition preparers, non-lawyers who formulate bankruptcy petitions. After 2 preparers were discovered to be assisting abusive serial filers, both agreed to stop when McEwen threatened to make them return customer charges.
Another preparer agreedconsented to stop doing petitions for Chapter 13 repayment cases, the kind filed by the Tesches. He had prepared 10 of the couples 11 petitions.
Contact Susan Taylor Martin at email@example.com or -LRB-727-RRB-Â 893-8642. Follow @susanskate.